TYPE OF REVIEW : GOOD OL’ REVIEW
Ending spoiler, but not much of one since it’s definitely predictable and as expected.
I first decided to check out GMA’s Hiram na Alaala because I liked the main cast and was very happy to see Kris Bernal getting a major lead role in what appeared to be a straight drama. The concept of the series, “shared memories,” was also intriguing. But the Baguio setting, charming chemistry between Kris Bernal and Rocco Nacino and the abundance of Ilocano dialogue was what kept me interested.
The story progressed well enough and it quickly and effectively established Kris Bernal and Rocco Nacino’s Andeng and Otep as a couple you could easily root for. Naturally, if you’re watching this or any Filipino drama, you know what’s up. Rocco Nacino is 2nd lead to Dennis Trillo, so of course Andeng and Otep are not meant to be.
That would be fine and all, but the show itself as it developed over the first month or so (including a very slow few weeks) made it appear that an Andeng-Ivan (Dennis Trillo) endgame was just not possible. Andeng had absolutely no feelings for Ivan and even when Otep was presumed dead, she clung to Ivan believing he really was some reincarnation of her beloved Ilocano-speaking Otep. (Don’t ask.)
Intriguing soapyness, no doubt. And that all came to a thrilling climax when Otep popped up alive at Ivan and Andeng’s wedding.
At that point, I thought; Now the big drama and conflict begins. I was interested in seeing where the story would go from there.
I still knew the endgame would be Dennis Trillo and Kris Bernal’s characters ending up together (it’s in the darn title card, for goodness sakes). But at that point, I saw absolutely no way that was possible without turning everyone on the show into idiotic psychopaths and throwing the goodwill the show had at the start right down the drain.
And that’s pretty much what happened.
I definitely did not expect the show would make a complete 180 and basically crawl through contrived mental insanity, random obsessive pregnant women and graphic torture porn/spousal abuse that had absolutely zero relevance to the main story.
Speaking of relevance, the main premise of “hiram na alaala” or borrowed memories ended up inconsequential, despite Andeng’s contrived narration in the final scene of the series.
Otep being diagnosed with PTSD and seeing how he and his family and girlfriend deal with it would’ve made for a very enlightening story. This isn’t something that is often, or even ever touched upon on Philippine television. Definitely not in a serious manner, at least.
What became increasingly evident was that the show pretty much used PTSD as a reason to basically throw someone you supposedly love to the side and lose your virginity to the other guy who has issues of his own, not related to any post traumatic stress.
So, the typical “turn the 2nd lead into a kidnapping/baril-toting psycho” trope was very much present here even though they appeared to be avoiding most Filipino soap opera tropes at the beginning. And so the series wrapped up this week, of course with an Ivan/Andeng ending. But without any foundation or justification to make it at all believable.
What’s even worse is that the series wasted such a solid cast in Kris Bernal, Rocco Nacino, Dennis Trillo and especially Lauren Young. All deserved better. Even Sheena Halili who was more of a lead actress than Lauren Young was given the opportunity for.
Lauren Young must have done something to piss off the writers of the series because instead of being one of the lead actors of the series (as advertised and title carded), she merely popped up from time to time as if she was some kind of guest star playing a (literal) crazy woman. Definitely one of the many inexplicable story decisions on a show that collapsed halfway through.
“Ay apo!” indeed.
Once a very promising and fresh series became a gratuitously violent and nonsensical example of what’s wrong with contemporary Filipino drama.
7 thoughts on “Good Ol' Review: Ay apo! GMA's Frustratingly Disappointing Hiram na Alaala”
This one reminds me of why I detest Princess and I’s ending so much, as much as I love its first 8 months. PAI had it worse. Way worse. Everyone, including the heroine, became outright idiots so that they can throw in a single fanservicey scene at the end. Nothing that was built in the story for much of is run mattered and the ending was done merely to whet the appetite of the teenage diehards of a certain teenstar that must not be named.
That’s why I stop watching the show the story line was too crazy for me.
I wonder how the unnecessary and years too early Pangako Sa Yo remake will turn out? lol
They could have at least cast a real actor for Jericho’s role, but no, they just have to give it to that teenstar. And yeah, it is unnecessary, and was made only to cash in on that guy’s (dwindling) popularity. They will probably turn it into a teenybopper show to please the guy’s diehards. Let’s face it, everything about that “loveteam” is only about the network selling the guy. And sadly, basic from Kathryn Bernardo’s latest performances, she has totally lost a lot of the power that made her such a compelling actress to watch, she is now just tied down to that guy.
Yeah, I guess when they want to just milk their loveteam dry while people are still interested, they aren’t going to be giving Kathryn any roles that would allow her to actually act instead of just being cute and kilig. Too bad.
Excellent review above…. I did recognize the multiple problems of HNA but I don’t know why I kept hoping all the wrong things will be made right in the end. Well, I was wrong. I guess, hindi ako sanay manood ng tele-serye. Why did I feel cheated and insulted!
Yeah, I myself am sanay sa mga teleserye, but I always still hope that it will turn out great even though I know will be disappointed, and like you said, cheated and insulted. =(