The 23rd Race around the world is done. This was an interesting season, yet oddly bland at the same time.
Even though this season was filmed back in July, it premiered on television right after the series’ only 2nd Emmy loss. So expectations were still a little high that this season needed to wow or at least prove that TAR still deserved to be nominated in the category it has dominated since its creation, let alone actually win it.
Unfortunately, the first half or even 2/3 of the season pretty much justified the loss. The teams were forgettable, the tasks were uninspired and the locations were uninteresting. TAR23 started off pretty much encapsulating all the criticisms fans have had about the show these last few years.
You couple the “Meh” feeling of TAR23 with the news that TAR24 was some kind of returning Racers season, it just made everything even less exciting.
It wasn’t until the last couple of Legs that TAR23 finally perked up. Competition was heated, the tasks and locations were excellent and the teams managed to finally show some personality instead of being either absolutely lifeless or being too big of a camwhore. Plus, the spoiled teams of TAR24 forced me back into rooting hard for TAR23 to deliver the goods because TAR24 certainly isn’t appearing to do that.
Anyway, the first few Legs, as I said were completely uninspired and relied too much on typical TAR tasks and horribly linear Leg design. Not even camels could elevate “meh” Legs. But as soon as TAR23 got to Indonesia, things started looking up.
Leg 9 had to be one of the best Legs on TARUS in the last few seasons. It had some amazing tasks, amazing drama and really showed off the location. Leg 10 and Leg 11 ramped up the drama and real competition and coupled that with great tasks.
The final Leg was alright. Alaska is a beautiful place, but I really wished they had not wasted a great final memory task by not using it for drama and instead spending half the last hour playing in the ice.
Overall, TAR23 is a pretty middling season. I didn’t write a season wrap-up for TAR22 since I had to watch the final episode more than a month after it aired. But these last few seasons have started to make me see my previous least favorite season (TAR7) in a much better light. Eeek. Whatever the outcome of TAR24, I’m already looking to TAR25 and hope that that milestone season will be the one that gets TAR back on track and into a new golden era.
Final Team Rankings
in subjective order
Such an odd cast, honestly.
I guess the elimination of Hoskote & Naina in the first Leg was a sign of the blah season that was to come. I really was hoping they would be Ron & Christina 2.0. And it appeared that they had the makings of it too. In one Leg, Hoskote had already delivered plenty of his own Real Truth Flavor® and it would’ve only gotten more hilarious from there. It sucked how horrible they were in the Leg though.
Tim & Marie, I really disliked in the first half of the Race. Their bickering exes act was really grating and felt so forced and fake. You just know they were playing up to the cameras most of the time. And that forced aspect of their characters really overshadowed that they were very competent Racers. They definitely stepped it up as the Race went on and when they toned down their bickering, it seemed more natural and they became more likeable. Even more when other teams did complete 180s, character-wise, they surprisingly became a team to root for by the end.
Rowan & Shane as my #3 team from this season. Wow. That says a lot. They may have been total fodder, but I would’ve actually wanted to see them longer in the Race if only to see them be somewhat amusing. Or at least until that wedding bride Detour in Leg 10. Tim & Danny deserve much kudos for really playing the game and being smart about keeping the other teams at bay. That they wouldn’t let themselves be played or used was great. But their defeatist attitude at times really dragged them down.
If only we saw the Ally & Ashley in their Final Leg for the entire Race, they could’ve been two of the fiercest all-female teams ever. But instead, they hitched their wagon to the Afghanimal Train and it was bad. They relied too much on them and when they didn’t, they would lag behind. And not to mention the whole showmance business has no place on TAR. Meanwhile, Chester & Ephraim were just one bad plane move away from actually making a big impact on the Race.
Jason & Amy were a generic hot dating couple until their fight with Tim & Marie. That’s when we finally saw some personality out of them. It wasn’t a necessarily good personality (condescending Jason), but it was finally them showing some interesting bits and pieces. That then descended into their strange alliance with Nicole & Travis which climaxed with the laughable Road Block in Japan. Them calling themselves one of the best teams to ever Race also rubs the wrong way. No, you two are not one of the best teams to ever run the Race.
Nicky & Kim fell forward every Leg of the Race. Just when you thought they had stepped up their game, they would fall right back into falling forward. They weren’t afraid to ruffle feathers, but they never had the Race skills to back it up. And they were saved twice by non-elimination Legs, one of them without even a Speed Bump.
Brandon & Adam were alright, but pretty forgettable despite their bigger personalities. But we just had James & Abba who were much more interesting.
Nicole & Travis… Wow. The biggest collapse in the history of The Amazing Race. After recovering from their first Leg blunder, they ran a consistent and strong Race. They seemed liked the team to beat. Then everything just imploded. Nicole had meltdown after meltdown at Road Blocks while Travis started giving vaguely divorce-type confessionals about being disappointed that his wife sucks at challenges on The Amazing Race. Their edit on the show was the oddest thing I’ve ever seen on the Race too. From strong competitors to hypocritical and sanctimonious fakes who didn’t practice what they suddenly preached. So odd.
And then there’s Leo & Jamal. Ultimate camera whores who played to the cameras and mugged them every chance they got… except for when they actually had to Race from behind. That’s when they became tolerable. But then the hooting and hollering would return, the cockiness appear and the wifey talk flood out of their mouths. I definitely hope we won’t have to see them on a future TAR ever. Ever.
18. TAR18: UB
(regardless of winner)
17. TAR11: AS
|GROUP of TEAMS
5. TAR11: AS
|MY ALL-TIME TEAMS
1. Ronald & Christina (TAR12/18)
1. Teri & Ian (TAR3/AS)
1. Charla & Mirna (TAR5/AS)
4. Kris & Jon (TAR6)
5. Linda & Karen (TAR5)
6. Brendon & Rachel (TAR20)
7. John Vito & Jill (TAR3/AS)
8. David & Margaretta (TAR1)
9. Meredith & Gretchen (TAR7)
10. Brian & Ericka (TAR15)
11. The Linz Family (TAR8)
12. Max & Katie (TAR22)
13. Ernie & Cindy (TAR19)
14. Nat & Kat (TAR17)
15. Brook & Claire (TAR17)
16. Erwin & Godwin (TAR10)
17. Natalie & Nadiya (TAR21)
18. Trey & Lexi (TAR21)
19. Pam & Winnie (TAR22)
|NON TOP 3 TEAMS THAT
SHOULD HAVE GONE FURTHER
1. Ron & Christina (TAR18)
2. Teri & Ian (TARAS)
3. John Vito & Jill (TAR3)
4. The Gaghan Family (TAR8)
5. Linda & Karen (TAR5)
6. Bopper & Mark (TAR20)
7. Meredith & Gretchen (TAR7)
8. Charla & Mirna (TAR5)
9. Natalie & Nadiya (TAR21)
10. The Paolo Family (TAR8)
11. Pam & Winnie (TAR22)
12. Gary & Mallory (TAR17)
13. Joseph & Monica (TAR9)
14. Bill & Cathi (TAR19)
15. Jim & Marsha (TAR5)
16. Steve & Allie (TAR16)
17. Hoskote & Naina (TAR23)
FINAL 3 TEAM (NON-WINNERS)
1. Brook & Claire (TAR17)
1. Kris & Jon (TAR6)
1. Teri & Ian (TAR3)
1. Charla & Mirna (TARAS)
1. Ronald & Christina (TAR12)
6. Ken & Gerard (TAR3)
6. Kelly & Jon (TAR4)
6. Dustin & Kandice (TARAS)
9. Gary & Mallory (TAR18)
10. Max & Katie (TAR22)
11. Jaymes & James (TAR21)
12. Brian & Ericka (TAR15)
13. Eric & Jeremy (TAR9)
14. Brendon & Rachel (TAR20)
15. Nicolas & Donald (TAR12)
16. Frank & Margarita (TAR1)
17. Trey & Lexi (TAR21)
18. Ken & Tina (TAR13)
19. Tim & Marie (TAR23)
24 thoughts on “The Amazing Race 23 Wrap-Up”
why the hell is tar 8 so high?
Because it is an excellent season with possibly one of the best group of teams ever. Definitely tops anything post-TAR12.
You mention as well that TAR 7 is your least favorite season. Why?
Well, it used to be my least favorite season. But like I said up above, I’ve started to see it in a much better light after the last couple of seasons. It’s not my least favorite anymore, but I still don’t necessarily like it very much. It has one of the worst, most unlikeable casts ever. Meredith & Gretchen aren’t enough to carry a cast of just unlikeable people. And Rob & Amber are just horrible. They really drag the season down.
why do you like TAR 3?
Because it is AMAZING. Awesome teams. Awesome locations. Awesome tasks. All memorable. The two Vietnam Legs are two of the best Legs ever on the Race.
Here’s what I posted over at Sucks, the message board of my favorite things about TAR3:
-Teri & Ian bottomgoddessing before Race ownage
-Ken & Gerard hilarity
–Ken & Gerard almost getting killed by a train
-“Why did you take your pants off!?”
-“This is more important than your pants falling down!” / “Oh, you think so?” / “Yeah I think so. You’re not modest.”
-Switzerland non-elimination footrace
-Heather donkey faceplant
-Andre & Damon getting detained
-Dennis & Andrew Fast Forward fail
-Aaron & Arianne villainy
-John Vito & Jill unnauseating “nice couple”
-Gina & Sylvia being more interesting than most post-TARAS teams
-BASKET BOATS vs BASKET BIKES
-In fact, both Vietnam Legs being excellent
I’m still curious why is it TAR 7 being dead last your finale rankings. I thought it was an exciting finale and had one of the most suspenseful finish.
I guess that has to do with my general dislike of TAR7. But I thought the finale was pretty boring with teams I didn’t really care about. Other than the last minute taxi fare drama, it was a blah finale.
Even if you dislike TAR 7 I think it had some memorable moments:
1. Romber convincing Ray & Deana and Meredith & Gretchen to quit the Roadblock.
2. Gretchen busted her head.
3. Brian & Greg’s cameraman got injured.
4. Brian & Greg beating Ray & Deana in a footrace.
5. Lynn & Alex brought to the wrong palace.
6. Joyce shaved her head.
7. Of course, the taxi fare drama.
The meat Road Block might be the single worst moment in the history of TAR. Glorified quitting. Ewe.
But Meredith & Gretchen’s awesomeness with her head, the bad elephant and making Final 4 isn’t enough to redeem the season for me. Even Brian & Greg’s epic Leg or the head shaving Fast Forward. But I have put it above recent seasons, it’s just that I’m not going to be watching TAR7 again anytime soon.
This my personal rankings of all TAR seasons. (I haven’t watch TAR 2, TAR 4 and TAR 6 yet)
1. TAR 5
2. TAR 3
3. TAR 7
4. TAR 12
5. TAR 17
6. TAR 18:UB
7. TAR 20
8. TAR 21
9. TAR 1
10. TAR 11:AS
11. TAR 10
12. TAR 22
13. TAR 23
14. TAR 19
15. TAR 9
16. TAR 14
17. TAR 15
18. TAR 16
19. TAR 13
20. TAR 8
TAR2, TAR4 and TAR6 are good seasons. =]
Since you have no season wrap-up for TAR 22, can you post your final subjective team ranking for TAR 22?
Good idea. Sure. If not in the next week, maybe after the TAR24 finale.
Why is it Flo & Zach are so high at you winner rankings? I can’t stand Flo she is probably the most annoying person and worst teammate you could ever have on TAR.
Yes she was, but the rest of the winners are either horrible or worse, boring. lol
Dave’s totally got her beat though in the “most annoying” category hehe
How was TAR 22 for you overall?
Oh yeah, I never wrote a Wrap-up for TAR22 as I was in the Philippines with no internet during its final weeks.
I thought it was alright. An average season overall, but I think it got better with each week. I definitely liked a lot of the teams, Max & Katie and Pam & Winnie especially.
Bates & Anthony were boring winners.
And I was just really sad about the whole Vietnam controversy. I don’t think it was warranted.
I just rewatch TAR 7. Boy! I know already the reason why you don’t like the season. Most teams were bland and unforgettable other than Rob & Amber and Ray & Deana who I disliked. Meredith & Gretchen and Uchenna & Joyce are the only likable teams. It had a weak cast.
It really was a weak cast. Without those four teams, and Ray & Deana really only because of that footrace with Brian & Greg, the season’s cast would really be horrible.
What can you say about Scotland Leg and the Finale of TAR 22?
The Scotland was fine. The U-Turn gave a lot of drama. Plus, Joey & Meaghan were finally eliminated! lol
The Finale was okay, but the last leg was too linear, as always. Loved the TAR8 Switchback though.
I just finished watching TAR 6. Boy! the ending was heartbreaking. I almost cry when Kris & Jon lost. Not happy about Freddy & Kendra winning. Kendra is a racist bitch.
Yeah, Kris & Jon would’ve been amazing winners. One of the saddest finales, definitely. Especially since they were so close.